The Growing Vulnerability of Functional Claims for Display and Mapping Location Patents: A § 101 Defense to Patent Troll Litigation
With patent troll filings rising compared to Q3 2025[1]—and PTAB proceedings becoming less available following recent changes at the USPTO—defendants are once again asking whether 35 U.S.C. § 101 remains an effective tool for challenging the patents asserted by non-practicing entities (NPEs).
The short answer is increasingly yes—particularly where the asserted patent is directed to:
- displaying or transmitting information on conventional devices; or
- monitoring or displaying information through GPS or similar tracking technologies.
Display-Technology Patents
The Federal Circuit’s recent decision in GoTV Streaming, LLC v. Netflix, Inc., 166 F.4th 1053, 1063–67 (Fed. Cir. 2026), provides a notable example of a display-technology patent invalidated under § 101. The court’s opinion draws a clear line between eligible technological improvements and ineligible functional claims:
On one side of the line (requiring a determination favoring the patent challenger at step one) are claims that simply call for the use of computers and networks as tools to carry out an abstract idea, using their ordinary functions without specific hardware or process advances in those functions, e.g., receiving inputs, storing and retrieving, processing, outputting (including displaying), and transmitting. On the other side of the line (ending the Alice inquiry, without proceeding to step two) are claims that call for a concrete asserted improvement in how those functions are carried out, which requires more than result-focused functional language and more than just using those functions in the context of specifically identified content.
Id. at 1064 (emphasis added). Applying that framework, the Federal Circuit held the asserted claims ineligible because they merely recited the functional result of rendering visual content on device screens (according to the ordinary capabilities of the receiving device), without identifying any concrete technological improvement in how that result was achieved. Id. Importantly, GoTV Streaming is part of a broader trend in which the Federal Circuit has invalidated patents that rely on high-level functional claiming directed to collecting, manipulating, transmitting, or displaying information. See AI Visualize, Inc. v. Nuance Commc’ns, Inc., 97 F.4th 1371, 1378 (Fed. Cir. 2024) (holding that “obtaining, manipulating, and displaying data” are abstract concepts); see also Hawk Tech. Sys., LLC v. Castle Retail, LLC, 60 F.4th 1349, 1356–57 (Fed. Cir. 2023) (holding ineligible claims directed to “viewing [of] multiple simultaneously displayed and stored video images on a remote viewing device of a video surveillance system”).
Although these decisions do not establish a categorical rule against display-technology patents, they strongly suggest that patents claiming desired results at a high level of generality—particularly through functional language untethered to a specific technological solution—face an increasing risk of invalidation under § 101. Defendants confronting NPE assertions involving the display, transmission, processing, or monitoring of information should therefore evaluate whether an early eligibility challenge offers a viable path to dismissal.
Mapping-Location Patents
A recent example of mapping-location patent being held ineligible is NantWorks, LLC v. Niantic, Inc., No. 2024-2216, 2026 WL 1098161, at *3 (Fed. Cir. Apr. 23, 2026). There, the Federal Circuit held representative claim 7 of the ’518 patent ineligible, explaining that the claim merely “determine[d] a user’s location, determine[d] relevant information to give the user, and display[ed] that content,” and characterizing the invention as no more than selecting and presenting information based on a user’s geographic location. Id. at *3 (emphasis added). In reaching that conclusion, the court relied on two recent rulings. The first is International Business Machines Corp. v. Zillow Group, Inc., 50 F.4th 1371, 1374–75, 1378 (Fed. Cir. 2022), in which the court held the claims ineligible where a “user draws a shape on a map to select that area of the map” and the system then filters and displays information associated with that area. The second, Sanderling Management Ltd. v. Snap Inc., 65 F.4th 698, 701, 703 (Fed. Cir. 2023), the court held that claims directed to loading digital functions when a user entered a particular geographic location were drawn to the abstract idea of providing information or functionality upon satisfaction of a condition, such as “matching GPS coordinates to a location.” Id (emphasis added).
Although not discussed in NantWorks, the Federal Circuit’s decision in Beteiro, LLC v. DraftKings Inc., 104 F.4th 1350, 1355 (Fed. Cir. 2024), is consistent with the cases above. There, the Federal Circuit agreed with the district court that Beteiro’s claims were “directed to the abstract idea of exchanging information concerning a bet and allowing or disallowing the bet based on where the user [was] located.” Id. (emphasis added).
The common thread running through NantWorks, Int’l Bus. Machs. Corp., Sandlering, and Beteiro is that each case involved claims using geographic location or GPS-derived information as a trigger for providing, filtering, enabling, disabling, or displaying content or functionality. Put simply, each claim followed the same three steps: (1) determine where the user is; (2) compare that location to predetermined geographic criteria, such as a drawn map boundary, a geofence, or a jurisdiction; and (3) take an action based on the result. The Federal Circuit has repeatedly concluded that using GPS coordinates, geofences, map locations, or other location data as a condition for delivering information or authorizing activity does not constitute a technological improvement to computers, networks, GPS systems, or location-tracking technology itself. Rather, such claims are directed to the abstract idea of making decisions based on a user’s geographic location and implementing those decisions with conventional computing technology.
Again, while not a categorical rule, these decisions suggest that claims using geographic location or GPS information as a trigger for decision-making are increasingly likely to be found ineligible under § 101 absent an improvement to the underlying mapping or geolocation technology.
Conclusion and Takeaways
In the twelve years since Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International, 573 U.S. 208 (2014), motions under 35 U.S.C. § 101 have seen a natural ebb and flow of success. With PTAB review limited by recent USPTO changes, defendants have questioned whether § 101 remains a meaningful defense against NPE litigation. Recent Federal Circuit decisions suggest that it does—particularly where the asserted claims are drafted at a high level of functional abstraction and focus on the transmission, display, or location-based use of information. While patent eligibility remains a case-specific inquiry and no categorical rules have emerged, the Federal Circuit’s recent precedents reflect a growing willingness to invalidate patents that claim desired results without identifying a concrete improvement in the underlying technology.
Several practical themes emerge from these decisions:
- Display and information-processing claims remain vulnerable when they merely collect, manipulate, transmit, monitor, or display information without improving how those functions are technologically performed.
- Result-oriented functional language is increasingly disfavored—particularly where claims recite what is accomplished rather than how it is accomplished.
- Location- and GPS-based patents face heightened scrutiny when geographic information is used merely as a trigger for providing content, enabling functionality, or authorizing transactions.
- Early dismissal remains a realistic possibility where the asserted claims can be characterized as abstract information processing or location-based decision-making implemented on conventional computer technology.
Accordingly, defendants confronted with NPE assertions involving display technologies, geolocation systems, mapping platforms, GPS-triggered functionality, or similar software patents should evaluate whether a § 101 motion offers a cost-effective path to narrowing (or eliminating) the case at the outset. In an environment where PTAB challenges may be less available or less predictable, patent eligibility is re-emerging as a viable defense against functional claims untethered to a specific technological innovation.[2]
[1] See Patent Dispute Report: Q3 2026, Unified Patents, https://www.unifiedpatents.com/insights/2026/10/16/patent-dispute-report-q3-2026.
[2] This article is the third part of a series of articles addressing NPE litigation. The two previous articles can be found:
- 12.22.2025 | Maynard Article | Patent Trolls: Seven Steps to Stop Them and How They Are Contributing to the 20% Uptick in Patent Litigation in 2025
- 07.31.2026 | Maynard Article | No Marking, No Damages, No Case: A Hidden Defense to Patent Troll (NPE) Litigation
About Maynard Nexsen
Maynard® is a nationally ranked, full-service law firm with more than 600 attorneys nationwide, representing public and private clients across diverse industries. The firm fosters entrepreneurial growth and delivers innovative, high-quality legal solutions to support client success.