The EEOC Stepped Back from Disparate Impact. Employers’ Exposure Didn’t.
On October 28, 2026, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) voted 2-1 to rescind its 2012 Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The rescission took effect immediately, and the EEOC is also moving to rescind the interpretive portions of the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (UGESP), which have governed how employers validate selection tools since 1978.
Employers may read these developments as permission to relax their background check and selection practices, but that would be a mistake. The federal government has changed its enforcement priorities, not the law, and a growing number of states are moving in the opposite direction.
What Is Disparate Impact?
Unlike disparate treatment, disparate impact requires no intent to discriminate. A facially neutral policy, such as a blanket felony ban or a pre-employment test, can be unlawful if it disproportionately screens out a protected group and the employer cannot show it is job related and consistent with business necessity. The theory traces to the Supreme Court’s 1971 decision in Griggs v. Duke Power Co., and Congress codified it in Title VII in 1991.
What the EEOC Has Done
- Rescinded the criminal records guidance. The 2012 guidance cautioned against treating arrests as proof of misconduct, discouraged blanket exclusions, and recommended an individualized assessment of the offense, the time elapsed, and the job. The EEOC says the rescission does not revive older policy statements or require employers to abandon lawful practices adopted under the guidance. No replacement guidance has issued.
- Moved to rescind the Uniform Guidelines. The UGESP (codified at 29 C.F.R. Part 1607) directs employers to validate selection procedures that have an adverse impact. On October 16, 2026, the EEOC sent a final rule rescinding its interpretive portions for White House review, with final action projected for November 2026 and an effective date in January 2027. As of mid-November, the rule remained under review, so current obligations remain in place. The Department of Justice has submitted a parallel rescission of its own version of UGESP.
What Has Not Changed
- Title VII still prohibits disparate impact discrimination. Disparate impact liability comes from the statute, not agency guidance.
- Private plaintiffs can still sue. An applicant can still file a charge, obtain a right-to-sue notice, and bring a disparate impact claim, including as a class action, under existing case law.
- The roadmap is gone, but the risk is not. Ironically, the guidance helped employers, too, by giving them a recognized framework to show a policy was job related. That benchmark is now gone.
States Are Moving in the Opposite Direction
In September 2026, the attorneys general of fourteen states issued joint guidance affirming that disparate impact liability remains enforceable under their civil rights laws and applicable federal law. The guidance recommends standardized, job-relevant qualifications and transparent hiring, advancement, and termination policies, signaling what these states will look for. Some states have written disparate impact liability directly into their own civil rights statutes. Those laws generally track the Title VII framework: the employer must show that a challenged practice is job related and consistent with business necessity, and the practice may still be unlawful if a less discriminatory alternative would serve the same purpose. State and local fair chance laws also continue to restrict how and when employers may consider criminal history. After the midterms, expect more state activity.
Even in states that have no disparate impact statute of their own, Title VII still applies. And a company-wide policy that is lawful in one state may still create exposure for employees and applicants from other states.
Practical Considerations
As the saying goes, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Employers should consider the following:
- Do not abandon individualized assessments. Avoid blanket exclusions and arrest-only decisions, and weigh the offense, its timing, and the job.
- Keep validating your selection tools. Validation remains a strong defense. Keep your studies and monitor selection rates.
- Document the alternatives you considered. A record that you considered less discriminatory options will strengthen your defense under federal and state law.
- Map your workforce. Identify where you hire and which of those jurisdictions have codified disparate impact, joined the multistate guidance, or adopted fair chance laws.
- Review your policies now. Update handbooks, applications, and hiring criteria, and train recruiters and managers.
- Protect your analysis. Conduct adverse impact analyses at the direction of counsel to help preserve privilege.
The EEOC’s retreat changes who is likely to bring a claim, not whether one can be brought. Maynard Nexsen regularly advises employers to ensure compliance with Title VII, state civil rights and fair chance laws, and other applicable state and federal laws. With questions about disparate impact, background checks, or selection procedures, contact any member of our Employment & Labor Law Practice Group for advice.
About Maynard Nexsen
Maynard® is a nationally ranked, full-service law firm with more than 600 attorneys nationwide, representing public and private clients across diverse industries. The firm fosters entrepreneurial growth and delivers innovative, high-quality legal solutions to support client success.